Is HR Really on Your Side?

EN | FR

The HR Leader's Edge — Edition #6

Is HR Really on Your Side?

By Heidi Klotz, Professional Goal-Centric Certified Coach & Fractional CHRO

Published August 5, 2026

A leader I was coaching once looked at me and asked, point blank, "Whose side are you actually on?"

I could have given her the polished answer. The one about HR serving all stakeholders equally, everyone's partner, everyone's advocate. Instead I told her the truth. Not really. And here's why that matters more than you'd think.

Who signs the paycheck

HR professionals are employees of the company, full stop. We're hired by the business, we report to the business, and our performance is measured by how well we serve the business. That's not a dirty secret. It's the job. According to SurveyMonkey's 2026 "Bridging the HR Gap" report, most employees already sense this. Seventy one percent said they trust HR, yet they still see HR as more aligned with the employer than with them. They're not wrong.

But that's only half the picture.

The pull that never goes away

Anyone who's spent real time in this profession knows there's a moral weight to it too. You sit across from someone going through a divorce, a health scare, a layoff they didn't see coming, and you carry that. You know when a manager is mistreating their team long before it shows up in an exit interview. You care, genuinely, about whether people are treated fairly, paid fairly, given a real shot.

So HR lives in a permanent tension. Employer advocate and employee advocate, at the same time, every single day. Anyone who tells you that tension resolves cleanly hasn't done the job long enough.

HR isn't the police

Here's where I think the profession gets misunderstood, by employees and by HR people themselves. Too many of us fall into the role of enforcer. The one who shows up when something's gone wrong, hands out the policy, closes the investigation, and disappears until the next issue.

That's not what HR is supposed to be. At its best, HR is a strategic business partner. Someone who understands the business well enough to sit in the room where decisions get made, not just the room where they get communicated afterward. Someone who can look at a restructuring, a leadership gap, a retention problem, and bring real judgment to it, not just process.

A good HR business partner earns trust from leaders because they understand the numbers, the strategy, and the pressure leaders are under. And they earn trust from employees because they don't disappear the moment things get uncomfortable. That combination, business fluency plus genuine care for people, is rare. It's also the entire job description, whether it's written down that way or not.

What this actually means for you

If you're an employee, understand this. HR is not your personal lawyer, and HR is not your enemy either. When you bring something to HR, especially as a leader, you're far more likely to get real help if you understand what HR can and can't do for you, and if you come with the business context, not just the complaint.

HR can be one of the most valuable relationships you build in your career. I've seen it change trajectories, protect people during hard moments, and open doors that wouldn't have opened otherwise. But it works best when you see HR clearly, not as a neutral referee, and not as the enemy, but as a partner with real constraints and a real conscience, doing its best to hold both at once.

That's the honest answer. Not really on your side. But not against you either. And understanding the difference is where the real value starts.

Heidi Klotz is a leadership coach and fractional CHRO based in Montreal, Quebec. She is a Professional Goal-Centric Certified Coach (Concordia University) and holds the CHRP, SHRM-SCP, CCP and GRP designations. Before founding Heidi Klotz Coaching & Leadership, she spent more than 20 years in senior HR roles at Merck, Bristol-Myers Squibb, Mattel, Ardene and AtkinsRéalis, where she was Vice-President of Total Rewards. She coaches online in English and French.